Come meet our amazing team: Our dedicated and tireless staff are what makes Family Eyecare the go-to clinic for an optometrist and eyewear in Millersburg OH, and the surrounding areas.

Greeting you at the front desk with a smile!

In today’s environment of ever changing technology, it is simply impossible to run an optometric practice that remains on the forefront of our profession without outstanding well trained people. Our goal at Family Eyecare as stated in our mission statement is to provide the latest eye care technology and professional services. This means our staff must be trained and constantly retrained in new procedures, equipment, and products as technology evolves. Our staff is the best because they work at it. They are the backbone of our practice. They are extremely competent at what they do and just as important, they genuinely care about our patients. You probably know many of them by name and we are proud of every one of them!

With almost 75 years of combined experience, we can take care of all your family eye care needs.

Dr. Nathan Atterholt, O.D.

Dr. Atterholt grew up in nearby Ashland County, and graduated from Hillsdale High School. He then attended the College of Wooster earning a Bachelor of Arts degree in Biology. He then attended The Ohio State University College of Optometry where he earned his Doctor of Optometry (O.D.) and Master’s of Science (M.S.) in Vision Science in 2011. He came to work at Family Eyecare Associates in 2014 and purchased the practice from Drs. James and Holly Conway in 2019.

Dr. Atterholt sees patients of all ages and has a special interest in pediatric eye care and ocular disease management. He manages patients with glaucoma, cataract, dry eye syndrome, and diabetic retinopathy among other conditions. He enjoys fitting patients in contact lenses, including daily disposable, astigmatism, bifocal, and specialty contact lenses.

Dr. Atterholt married his high school sweetheart, Amy, and together they have a son Rhett. They live on a farm and raise grain crops and pigs. Together, they enjoy traveling and spending time with family. Dr. Atterholt enjoys woodworking, golf, farming, and Notre Dame football. He is a member of the Lions Club, American Cancer Society Relay for Life, and Trinity Lutheran Church.

Dr. James Conway and Dr. Holly Conway

Dr. James along with his wife Dr. Holly met at Ohio State University and graduated from the College of Optometry in 1981. They founded Family Eyecare Associates that same year. They grew the practice from a small office in their home to the state-of-the-art facility of Glen Drive it occupies today. They sold the practice to Dr. Atterholt in 2019, but still continue to see patients of all ages. They are members of the American Optometric Association as well as Volunteers for Optometric Service to Humanity (VOSH).

Dr. James and Holly have done several mission trips with VOSH. In 2012, 2015, and 2019 they went on mission trips to Romania to do eye exams and fit glasses. Dr. James has gone to the Dominican Republic in 2018 and 2020 as well. Dr. Holly does Realeyes presentations to local students. The presentations advocate for proper eye care and educate students on eye health.

Dr. James and Holly have four children and four grandchildren. They enjoy traveling, biking, skiing, boating, and visiting their children. They are members of Millersburg United Methodist Church.

Ginny CPO

Certified Paraoptometric

Employed since 1993, over 25 years in the optical industry, Ginny is a Certified Paraoptometric. Ginny works in our lab several days a week, she also assists patients in frame and lens selections and contact lens trainings. Ginny’s responsibilities include checking in glasses orders, cutting lenses, ordering contact lenses, assisting at the front desk, and working with frame companies to purchase frames for our office.

Vickie ABOC, ABO

Certified Optician / Office Manager

Employed since 1999, Vickie is an ABOC, Certified Optician and the Office Manager. Another one of our versatile employees, she does patient pre-testing, contact lens trainings, special testing for glaucoma patients, assists patients with frame and lens selections, and works in the lab. E-mail her directly at with any questions you may have.

Johnna CPO

Front Desk, Certified Paraoptometric,

Johnna has been employed since 2000, she is a Certified Paraoptometric. Her responsibilities include working the front desk, frame and lens selections, and contact lens trainings. Some of her front desk responsibilities include answering phone calls, scheduling appointments, and ordering glasses.


Front Desk, Pretester

Employed since 2014, Bria assists with patient pre-testing, frame and lens selections and contact lens trainings and works at the front desk. Some of her front desk responsibilities include answering phone calls, scheduling appointments, and ordering glasses.


Front Desk, Pretester

Employed since 2014, Ramona is greeting patients at our front desk, assists with patient pre-testing, contact lens trainings, and frame and lens selections. Ramona also helps with special testing for our patients with glaucoma.


Billing & Insurance Specialist

Susan joined our staff in 2015 and is our Billing & Insurance Specialist. She works with multiple insurances submitting claims and looking up vision benefits for patients. Susan can also be found welcoming patients at our front desk and helps with patient pre-testing and contact lens trainings.


Front Desk

A member of our staff since 2016. Mary greets you with a smile at our reception desk. Some of her front desk responsibilities include answering phone calls, scheduling appointments, and ordering glasses. She also checks in our shipment of contacts every day and notifies our patients their order is here. Mary also assists with frame and lens selections and helps with special glaucoma testing.


Amy joined our staff in 2020 as our primary patient pretester. She collects valuable data for the doctors to analyze before the examination begins. She also helps with frame selections, eyewear orders, and scheduling appointments.


Kayla joined our staff in 2020 and serves in a variety of roles. She does frame selections, order processing, scheduling, and other administrative duties. She also does pretesting and special testing for glaucoma, diabetes, and macular degeneration.